No matter how well you get along with your roommates, sharing a home with them can still be a challenge.
This is especially true when it comes to equally dividing cleaning and maintenance duties, splitting the costs of common appliances, and deciding what is and isn't shared.
This is especially true when not everyone is bringing in the same amount of income.
Redditor Remarkable_Break4617 shared a home with two roommates.
The original poster (OP) was furious to come home one day and discover that one of their roommates, Jake, had thrown out a recent purchase. When Jake refused to compensate the OP for the now-discarded purchase, the OP felt a change was necessary in their shared space.
After being told he was "overreacting" by his other roommate, the OP took to the subReddit "Am I The A**hole" (AITA), where he asked fellow Redditors:
"AITA for making my roommate pay for groceries he threw away?"
The OP explained why they demanded reimbursement from their roommate:
"Last week I spent about $85 on groceries, and on Tuesday I came home to find Jake had thrown almost everything in the fridge away because he said it smelled weird."
"There was chicken, cheese, vegetables, leftovers, etc."
"Some of it was literally unopened."
"I asked him why he didn't check with us first, and he said, 'It's $85; you'll survive'."
"That pissed me off, so I told him he owes me the money to replace it."
"He says he's not paying because it was shared food and he was just trying to clean the fridge."
"Our other roommate agrees he shouldn't have thrown it out but thinks I'm overreacting by asking for the full amount since we'd already eaten some of it."
"I told them fine, we can just stop sharing groceries completely next month."
"Now Jake is mad because he doesn't have a car and relies on me to get groceries when I go shopping."
"He also said if we're not sharing groceries anymore then he's not splitting the cost of paper towels, dish soap or trash bags either, even though those are household supplies."
"I feel like I'm always the one dealing with this stuff and now I'm somehow the bad guy for not wanting to waste my money."
"AITA?"
Fellow Redditors weighed in on where they believed the OP fell in this particular situation by declaring:
- NTA – Not The A**hole
- YTA – You're The A**hole
- NAH – No A**holes Here
- ESH – Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - More Information Needed
Everyone thought that Jake was being both impractical and illogical, with many also pointing out how his actions could easily be considered theft:
"NTA."
"If he thinks you can survive without $85, then he can show you how he survives without $85."- lumpthefoff
"NTA."
"Stand your ground OP."
"He just threw in household supplies to try and be spiteful, but he’ll lose out in the end as he doesn’t drive and will need a lift."-Popular-Parsnip8911
"NTA."
"And my guess is you didn’t see it in the trash can."
"He needs to pay you for his theft, and you need to use the money to get a mini fridge for your bedroom."- Remarkable_Table_279
"NTA."
"Next time Jake needs a ride somewhere, charge him $85 and call it even."- ExaminationFancy
"NTA."
"He definitely owes you the $85."
"Full price even though some was eaten, because it covers the labor of getting them again."
"I'd start looking for another roommate, OP."
"He's an a**hole."- discombobubolated
"NTA."
"Jake has shown you who he is, and you should believe him."
"He doesn't see anyone else's POV, which is going to make it f'n hard to deal with him."
"Tell him he still owes you most of the $85 he cost you, and an apology for acting like your money, your food, and your opinion don't matter."
"When he tries to fix what he broke, you'll consider trying a shared relationship again."
"Until then, get the fridge, shop for yourself."
"Keep your own paper towels and dish soap in your room."
"You might get cheated out of more than your share of garbage bags, but Jake will need that money for bus fare to the grocers."-katewithheld
"NTA."
"If he was really concerned, he should've waited for you to come home and you all together decide that the food should be thrown out."
"Unilaterally throwing out that much food based on an unsourced scent is stupid."
"What if the scent was from a dried spill in the fridge?"
"Threw out food over nothing."- DiamondPothos
"NTA."
"Hide all the household supplies, paper towel, dish soap, and lock your room so he can’t get any of your stuff."
"Get a lockbox for your food in the fridge."
"Stand your ground."
"Stop doing him a favor."
"He can Uber here, there, and everywhere."- DanaMarie75038
"NTA."
"Jake has realized the cost of his initiative is more than $85."
"Even if he made a genuine mistake, he's not helping himself by refusing to accept responsibility for it and recompense you to make it right."
"As for him losing a ride, he'll survive."- lemon_charlie
"NTA."
"He can learn to use Instacart."- _ohne_dich_
"NTA."
"If it’s only a few dollars, he can Uber and get his own groceries for the rest of the year…I’m guessing the $20+ per grocery trip will get real old real fast."- bloodfeier
"NTA."
"PettyMeTM would keep my own set of paper towels, dish soap, trash bags, etc. in a locked box, and he can sort himself out as he wishes."
"And not share food."- Puskarella
"NTA."
"Jake is one of those troublemakers whose comments have just enough of a single thread of truth that it makes it hard to call him out - we all know people like that."
"In reality, his behavior is obnoxious."
"Let him know he is on his own for rides, sharing anything, borrowing anything and you are more than happy to buy your own TP but if he throws out anything of yours again, you will log a report against him for theft."- Purple_Paper_Bag
"NTA."
"He should pay to replace them."
"If he was so concerned, he could have waited till you were all together or called/texted."
"He arbitrarily decided to toss everything, and in this economy, who the hell can afford to chuck food without actually checking to see if it was gone bad."
"He sounds immature."- RocketteP
"NTA."
"Get a lock for your bedroom to keep supplies you buy in there, and a locking box for the fridge for your cold food."
"Or get your own mini fridge - and lock it."
"He can just do without you providing you with anything from the store."- bkwormtricia
"NTA."
"But, so far, you haven't been able to make him pay it."
"He keeps throwing out a new retaliation."
"The thing is, he needs you more than you need him."
"Tell him that every time he wants a ride to get something from the store (or any similar help) will cost him $85."
"In the meantime, he can also take a bus to the store and buy sponges and mops and paper plates because he can’t use dishes if he isn’t cleaning them or paying for his share of cleaning supplies."
"You just need to get out of this group as soon as you can."- swillshop
"NTA, but he definitely is."
"Buy a mini refrigerator for your room and install a lock on it."
"Get a lock for your bedroom door (if you're renting, ask if it's okay first) and install a hidden camera in your room. Also, put all household supplies in your room."
"Your roommates are wrong; it's the principle behind it."
"Buy your own food and tell the roommates they should do the same."
"Don't cook for him."
"If he doesn't have a car, then he can call for a car service."- Otherwise-Wall-6950
"NTA."
"You need a new roommate."
"You should help Jake become an adult by allowing him to do his own grocery shopping."
"Not having a car is his problem."
"Maybe even ditch both roommates since the other doesn’t have a problem with your groceries being thrown away without compensation."- Monkeys_Funkl
"How could he smell unopened food?"
"NTA."
"For your own sanity, I’d relocate when the opportunity presents itself."
"Jake is a trash roomie and needs to throw himself out."- a_Vertigo_Guy
"NTA and tell him to get his damn groceries delivered."
"No more rides."- No_Bluebird7716
"NTA."
"If he wants to play petty games, then play petty games."
"He doesn't have a car, so I'm betting you win."- TheHighKnight
Assuming the OP has a steady income, Jake isn't exactly wrong that $85 isn't a huge loss in the grand scheme of things.
What Jake should be asking himself is how big a dent in his income $85 will be to him.
As one imagines, under this new "no sharing" rule, he'll probably be feeling his pockets getting steadily emptier...















