Child psychologists warn that treating twins as a single unit through matching clothes, shared possessions, or joint social circles blurs personal boundaries early on and can cause an unhealthy enmeshment and codependency or lead to resentment and lashing out as each twin is forced to compete for their own identity to be recognized as the shared one being forced on them.
As infants, the matching and sharing are fairly harmless, but by the time the twins begin to speak, the family should clearly recognize each child as a separate individual.
A family member who chose communal gifts for their preteen nephews turned to the "Am I The A**hole" (AITA) subReddit for feedback after the gifts caused conflict.
Braddic asked:
"AITA for refusing my sister's request to double my twin nephews' birthday presents?"
The original poster (OP) explained:
"My sister has 2 boys (Ed and Ton) who are twins, and a girl."
"For their 11th birthday, me and my partner bought the boys 2 presents to share. A duo combat robot set, operated by remotes so the robots can combat each other. And a technical robot building set. We usually give identical gifts, but this time we thought they can play together with the set and build the robot together as they enjoy building sets as well."
"We told them specifically that both presents were for the both of them. Then they each unwrapped one of the presents and played mostly with the combat robot set."
"A few months later, my sister asked me via the family WhatsApp to buy the duo combat robot set again for Ton because he didn’t like his own gift so much, he’s jealous of the gift his brother received, and is sad that he can’t play with it. I told her the robot set is his as well, both presents were for the both of them to share."
"My sister replied that Ed insists it’s his exclusively and that he doesn’t allow his brother to play with it. He’s playing with it with their sister and with other kids, but not with his twin brother. I told her we can call them to repeat that the presents are for both of them."
"My partner also has a twin brother and finds it ridiculous that they not sharing their communal gift, especially after my sister explained again it was for both of them. Ed insists he owns the duo combat set and that he will not share it. Ed doesn’t even allow Ton to play with it when he’s not using it. Ton can never touch it."
"My mom said we are the cause of Ton’s sadness, so we should make it up with rebuying the robot set."
"My partner insists that it’s ridiculous that the request is for us to buy another duo combat set, because the parents are letting Ed claim the gift for himself exclusively. My sister then bought Ton the same duo robot combat set herself. She was annoyed I didn’t rebuy it. Both boys now use their own duo set to play with their sister."
"My mom says I should be more understanding of Ton's disappointment. For me, the pattern in general of the kids taking things for granted rubs me the wrong way."
"If they don’t like a gift they just drop it to the floor, or say they don’t like it, or walk away without looking at the giver without any thanks. Or complain that the previous gift was boring and they hope for a better one next time."
"Anyway my mom and sister said I handled this wrong, and I need to buy Ton a duplicate duo robot set to make him feel better, and be more sensitive to Ton's feelings because he’s a kid."
"I learned from this to give gift cards from now on, with the same amount."
"AITA?"
"By the way, the duo combat robot set requires 2 players to operate 2 robots. This is the set that’s causing the row."
Redditors weighed in using the AITA voting acronyms:
- NTA - Not The A**hole
- YTA - You're The A**hole
- NAH - No A**holes Here
- ESH - Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - more information needed
Redditors decided the OP was not the a**hole (NTA), however many advised against communal gifts for older twins.
"NTA - your sister needs to parent her kids, not tell you how to spend your money. She needs to enforce that it’s shared property, not let one kid gaslight the other so he can be selfish." ~ Expensive-Bank-9270
"Though this may be the year they learn the twins don’t want to be regarded as a matched set after this. They need to share because obviously, but it’s now time to start buying them gifts unique to themselves." ~ ALostAmphibian
"All the people saying their mum should do a better job of parenting them, that is easy for someone to say, but as a parent of 12-year-old twin boys who do not get along at all and would never be able to share any present no matter how good our parenting was, just buy two presents next time and save her the hassle of having to play referee for kids who are likely going through a million hormonal changes at present."
"Mine disagree all day, every day. If someone bought mine a shared present, I’d likely say thanks a lot, then quietly sell or return it to a shop that takes no receipt returns, or buy a second one myself to save myself the stress."
"Having said that, NTA because in this case, it's not your issue to fix, but maybe don’t do the same thing next time." ~ sexwithnuns
"My two didn't get along at that age, and everyone said don't worry about it; they grow up to be friends. They have grown up now and both of them barely interact at all and will avoid activities they know the other one is at."
"I tried so hard to make them friends from a young age, but they just refused. They are angels to everyone else and have strong separate social networks."
"It saddens me though, because eventually I and their grandparents will pass and they won't have each other to rely on for support." ~ MySpoonsAreAllGone
"I always hated it when people bought communal gifts for my brothers and I. And we aren't even twins or triplets. When one wanted to use it for something, they'd have to ask the other two owners, and if they said no, our dad would overrule it and let them have it for whatever they wanted."
"So I never saw these gifts as ours together."
"Having said all that, you're NTA for refusing to buy another set. I am just pointing it out that it is better to buy individual gifts. It's bad enough that people see twins as one person instead of two individuals with different desires and needs." ~ EvokeWonder
"It’s not your fault really. But as a parent of twins, it sends the message that they can be considered one child. Independent and separate gifts are preferred." ~ Linit1207
"Bonus points when the gifts are not identical." ~ Pandas_dont_snitch
"When my twin sisters were younger, they got identical gifts because otherwise they would fight over them. Now that they're teenagers, they have very different personalities and get different gifts. Depends on the kids really." ~ Luxray
"My sister and I were given identical toys by my grandmother all the time, even though we're not twins."
"It was usually the toys our slightly younger cousin liked, so all three were the same. But cousins would always be a different color, like hers pink, ours both yellow, which sucked because we’d have to mark ours to tell apart."
"I’d aim for similar cost, but different items. At this point, seeing how petty they got they might be just getting gift cards for the next couple years." ~ Jayderae
"Yeah, I set the expectations right away with my family, no joint presents for birthdays, they will also always each get their own cake and happy birthday song. Xmas presents, I'll allow a big shared one, like a trampoline or swing set, just like other siblings get (in my experience)."
"Just because they are born on the same day doesn't mean they are the same person." ~ Ph4nt0m_666
"As a father of twins, one of their biggest complaints in life is having to share everything (even if they don't). They are very much independent people." ~ Kulandros
"Yeah, I hate to say it, but communal gifts actually suck. My sister and I were close in age (Irish twins), and relatives who didn't know us very well would frequently do this. Send gifts for both of us, like there was no distinction between us."
"Those gifts would either become a point of contention, a clear indication that it was meant for one or the other and they just bought two (we had very different interests), or just a thing we both had to pretend to like because it was an easy two kid gift neither of us wanted."
"I highly recommend finding out what each kid likes next time. And definitely give separate gifts." ~ Late_Resource_1653
"I also vote NTA, but yes, as a parent of twins, I’d rather you get them either two of the same thing or two totally separate gifts."
"They don’t like being treated as the same person and they already have to share so much, we feel like on their birthday they should get their own special things." ~why_renaissance
"It absolutely depends on the gift and the kid. My sister and I got a lot of communal gifts as kids and that caused some tension, but others worked out fine. Before giving communal gifts, I think there are questions you need to ask."
"Can this reasonably be played by everyone it's given to at the same time?"
"Is this likely to be enjoyed by all giftees?"
"Is one of the giftees likely to ruin it for the other(s) in some way?"
"Is there a good reason why I shouldn't give them each their own?"
"The last question was why all the video games and consoles I got as a kid were shared gifts, but my sister and I were also (reasonably) good at taking turns with them, occasionally enforced by parents."
"But OP didn't consider the 'ruin it' aspect, when knowing the kids have issues with sharing and jealousy. That's where things went wrong." ~InnateRidiculousness
OP provided an update:
"Thank you for all the feedback."
"I understand in hindsight we made a mistake by giving 2 large communal gifts instead of separate ones. I don’t have kids and my partner (who is a twin) is great with kids, so I followed his advice in getting these sets to share."
"We really made an effort to get them appropriate gifts, as they have been condescending about a few previous gifts that their parents suggested. We always have given them 2 of the same gifts before, at the request of their parents."
"This time we made an exception to be honest, to double the chance of them liking at least one of the two gifts."
It sounds like OP won't be making the same mistake again.















