Just because a person has a job that pays well doesn't mean they have the financial means to help everyone.
That job may pay for the necessities they need for their life.
Money is tight for everyone, including the ones who make it.
So when loved ones are struggling, there is only so much one can do.
Redditor u/bearmoonbears wanted to share her experience and get feedback, so she came to the "Am I The A**hole" (AITA) subreddit.
She asked:
"WIBTA if I didn’t help my sister and her husband financially?"
The Original Poster (OP) explained:
"I want to start off by saying that I (25 F[emale]) love my sister ('Jane,' 29 F)."
"However, she and her husband ('John,' 30 M[ale]) are struggling financially."
"They have a mortgage, student loans, credit card debt, etc."
"I recently got a new job that pays well."
"For the first time since law school, my bank account isn’t in the negatives."
"I recently went to visit John and Jane for our mom’s birthday."
"Jane started crying about their financial situation (like full-on bawling). "
"John recently got laid off, so money has been tight."
"Now, I want to help my sister because I love her."
"I already told them that they could have a portion of what I make when I sell my car because they are keeping it at their place for me."
"However, my dad asked me to give them more."
"I now have a car payment because my old one died on me, and I have to start paying back my student loans this month."
"Also, if I fail the February bar exam, I will lose my job and would like to have some savings in case that happens."
"There is a little part of me that doesn’t feel bad for them because my parents gave Jane money when she was in college and gave me nothing."
The OP was left to wonder:
"WIBTA if I didn’t help them beyond what I already promised?"
Redditors shared their thoughts on this matter and weighed in on some options to the question, AITA:
- NTA – Not The A**hole
- YTA – You're The A**hole
- NAH – No A**holes Here
- ESH – Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - More Information Needed
Many Redditors declared that OP was NOT the A**hole.
"NTA. You’re already offering them some money."
"If your father wants them to have more, he can supplement it himself."
"He’s certainly generous with other people’s money, isn’t he?" ~ MyLittlePiranha
"Your dad can give them all of his money; he has no right to say how you use your money." ~ Lavinia-Whateley
"Never tell anyone your salary."
"If you start helping, they will never get their act together." ~ Tight_Jaguar_3881
"Don't discuss your financial situation."
"You start telling them how much your salary is and how you are close to paying down student loans and how you are going to buy a car - this information gives them ammunition to then go to your parents and complain that you are not 'helping' them by spending every spare dime you have on their needs." ~ briomio
"Whenever you tell someone your salary, they think they deserve it more than you do."
"Take care of yourself; then if you feel inclined, you can share. "
"But it sounds like you first need to take care of yourself and pass the boards."
"At least wait until your job is secure before even thinking or helping them."
"Also, I have a very wealthy friend who helps her friends financially, and many of them don’t even say thank you, so be careful of those you help financially."
"Wait until U are older and more established to start sharing your hard-earned assets."
"You need to start contributing to your retirement plans at a young age, as you never know what tragedies may befall you, such as an auto accident."
"Which could change your life in an instant." ~ OldButAlive2022
"NTA. Keep your money so you avoid the same problems they are now having."
"If Dad wants them to be given money, he can do it."
"Good luck on the bar exam!" ~ NoAlternative9113
"NTA. While you say you have a job that pays well, you also have more bills."
"And that job, at this time, is not secure."
"Do not set yourself on fire to keep your sister warm."
"If she was receiving money when she was in college (and you were not), then it sounds like she might be used to getting covered whenever she wants."
"If finances are so tight, refer them to a financial counselor or organization and maybe a second job until her husband can get another one."
"Maybe even keep that second job until things aren't so tight."
"I get it, you love her."
"But you have your own responsibilities." ~ sparkio79
"NTA. You need to study for your exam and build a cushion."
"You weren't given any help."
"The golden child can figure it out."
"Once you pass your exam, concentrate on paying down YOUR student loans." ~ SeaworthinessDue8650
"NTA. Do NOT wreck yourself financially."
"Help where you can without putting yourself further into debt, and don't be afraid to say no."
"You'll find out quickly if they're really family or entitled parasites." ~ Main-Jelly4141
"NTA. It doesn't sound to me like you can afford to help anyone right now."
"It also sounds like your sister might be the golden child a bit."
"The fact that your parents helped her through school (but not you), and your dad is now putting pressure on you to help them out, is not a fair or healthy dynamic."
"You'd be putting your own financial security at risk by helping them."
"Giving a portion of your car sale is already more than enough." ~ HumbleBananaLoaf
"NTA. Once you start feeding the strays, it never stops. Ever."
"Do you want to support their lifestyle for the next umpteen years?"
"You have your own bills to pay and need to make it clear. Any 'leftover' money you have needs to go into retirement and other future long-term goals. "
"In 15 minutes, you’re going to be 48."
"Stay strong!" ~ ToastetteEgg
"It’s time for you to use your own money wisely so you don’t go into debt like they are, which means not giving money to people when you barely have enough for yourself."
"Give them your money, and pretty soon you’ll all be in debt."
"And the age you’re at is the time to start saving for your future."
"You may not have a lot of big expenses now, but you will eventually."
"By the way: I believe we should help those in need by giving to charity, but both your sister and her husband have a college education; you didn’t mention any disabilities, and I’m willing to bet they have not managed their money well."
"They also have a home."
"Just curious… do you own a home?"
"It sounds like you don’t, since you stored your car at their place."
"Before they dip into your income, they should consider downsizing into a more affordable home if that’s what it takes."
"The money you would lend them is money that you could be saving for a down payment on a home of your own," ~ Particular-Fun4216
"NTA. You're already giving them some financial help with the sale of the car; you've just gotten on your feet financially and need to be able to support yourself if things don't work out."
"If you do want to help them more, wait until after you're stable at your job and have a (minimum) 3 months built up for yourself if things go downhill."
"Then give them a one-time 'gift' of however much you are comfortable giving to them."
"Never risk going into debt to help someone else out of it." ~ Sad-Squirrel
"You are already giving them money in exchange for a favor."
"Your dad can give them money or keep his opinion to himself - your sister seems like the favorite child based on his past actions (helping her with college but not you), and he is way out of line for making this suggestion."
"You are young and starting out in a very difficult career."
"You've worked hard to get where you are, and you need the money you're making to prepare for the rest of your life."
"Your sister and her husband are two fully capable adults."
"John can get another job."
"Bank of Sister should not be something they get used to having as a bailout every time they hit a bump in the road."
"Last year my dog was attacked, and I accrued 12k in vet bills, and my dog still died."
"My brother loaned me 9k, which I repaid in 9 months."
"I did not ask - he offered. It was a wildly unexpected expense, and I really appreciated his help with bridging the gap so I didn't accrue credit card interest."
"But this is not what's happening with your sister - they're drowning in debt and want a gift of money - not a loan to be repaid during extenuating circumstances. NTA." ~ cloverthewonderkitty
"NTA. There's clearly a golden child here, and that's not you."
"I hope you haven't told them how much you make, because your go-to sentence going forward should be, 'I barely have 50 dollars for my expenses after paying my bills, I wish I could help.'"
"Never help these people with your money when they didn't bother extending theirs to you." ~ Top-Noise5959
"NTA. Don’t even start giving them money, or it will become the expectation forever."
"Get your own loans and bills paid and make yourself financially stable."
"Offering something from the sale of your car is very generous." ~ Agreeable-Body-7278
"NTA. Simply tell them what I've committed to give you is all I can give."
"End of discussion."
"My dad asked me to give them more."
"I love people who are generous with other people's money."
"Tell Dad if he wants them to have more, he can give it to them." ~ Own_Expert2756
Reddit is with you, OP.
Let your parents help her.
You have to worry about yourself.
Good Luck.















