Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Retirement Advisor Refuses To Help Parents Manage Money After They Switch To Company From TV Ad Instead

older couple looking over financial documents
Connect Images/Getty Images

There's an expectation in most cultures for children to take care of their parents as they age. But what if a parent specifically chooses someone else to help them?

Is the child's responsibility nullified by that choice? Is there any responsibility at all?


After all, parents choose to have children, but children don't choose to be born.

An adult child turned to the "Am I The A**Hole" (AITAH) subReddit for feedback over this question.

Similar to AITA, the AITAH subReddit allows posters to ask for advice and post about ending romantic relationships—both things that are banned on AITA. However, there are no required voting acronyms—only suggested ones—and no official final judgment declared.

Salty-Passenger-4801 asked:

"AITAH for refusing to help my parents after they move their money to another advisor?"

The original poster (OP) explained:

"I'm a retirement advisor who primarily does retirement planning, investments, tax planning, and insurance (Medicare and more)."

"When my dad turned 65 and retired, I helped both of my parents move their money from multiple 401(k)s into retirement accounts, set up their investments, manage their money, put together a tax plan, get Medicare set up, and establish a trust with an estate attorney."

"I didn't charge them a dime. They're my parents. How could I charge them?"

"About three months later, my dad went back to work, so I had to reverse course, cancel his Medicare, and cancel some of the other insurance because he was covered through his employer again. I still managed their money."

"Fast forward three years."

"Last week, my dad tells me out of nowhere that he wants to move all of his money to another financial advisor he found on TV. It's a well-known national company that advertises constantly and charges management fees of up to 1.25% annually. I actually manage money for quite a few people who left this company because they were unhappy with their services."

"I asked my dad why he wanted to move his money."

"He said, 'I'm not making any money'."

"I responded, 'Dad, you've made $166,000 in the past three years. What do you mean you're not making any money?'."

"He said, 'I should have made more than that'."

"I explained that his investments were set up according to his risk tolerance. If he wanted the potential for higher returns, he'd need to take on more risk, which at his age isn't necessarily a good idea. But he had already made up his mind."

"For context, my dad is incredibly easy to sell to. He's on his THIRD timeshare because he keeps getting suckered into buying them. When he buys a car, he won't negotiate and buys every add-on the salesperson suggests. Basically, if you're nice to him and tell him something is a great deal, he'll buy it."

"I know this guy talked a good game, didn't mention their costs and fees at all, and just made my dad feel like he was a friend. That's the part that pisses me off."

"Now, today, my dad calls me and asks, 'Hey, can you get our Medicare set up again and take care of the other insurance stuff you did before?'."

"I told him, 'You know what? I don't have time for that anymore. You should ask your new financial advisor if he can help you with that. If he can't, then I'd look on Google'."

"He said, 'Really?'."

I said, 'Yes,' and hung up."

"In my head, I'm thinking: If I'm not good enough for you to continue managing your money FOR FREE, why the hell should I keep doing all the other work for you that you still want/need me to do?"

"I don't mind helping my parents at all, that should be clear from this post. I've always been happy to do it. But now I feel like I'm good enough to handle other stuff for him, just not good enough to manage their investments anymore."

"Again, I'm not making any money from them, I'm pissed off that they're gonna get hosed on fees no matter what happens with their investments."

"So, AITAH?"

Some Redditors weighed in by using the AITA voting acronyms:

  • NTA - Not The A**hole
  • YTA - You're The A**hole
  • NAH - No A**holes Here
  • ESH - Everyone Sucks Here
  • INFO - more information needed

Redditors decided the OP was not responsible for their parents finances (NTA).

"NTA, but he’s your parent, and you can speak plainly with him and let him know your feelings. If he’s as gullible as you say, there’s something sad not helping him. Who knows if he has a subtle cognitive decline going on."

"I had those same feelings about how my husband had changed in a 2 year period. He turned out to have had a baseball size Glioblastoma tumor that explained a lot of his actions."

"I felt horrible about some of my thoughts before that diagnosis. Now I can’t take any of it back because he passed from that 14 months later." ~ Longjumping-Okra4462

"'If it's free, it must not be worth as much as something I pay for'. A lot of people think like that when it comes to family, even though this is your profession. My husband used to work for his mom and would try to talk to her about basic business strategies, but she would completely ignore his advice."

"A year later when things got really bad, she would then pay a bunch of money to an expert who would tell her the exact same things. I don't even think she ever realized it, because then she would explain it to my husband like it was some great epiphany. Sounds like your parents are doing the same thing."

"In three years you can check in with them to see how their portfolio has performed, less the commissions. I am betting they will be surprised to see how much they end up paying for what they previously got for free. As for helping them out now with Medicare and insurance, I see nothing wrong with letting him try on his own."

"Maybe he can begin to appreciate what you have done for him in the past and made look too easy. Especially if his new advisor does it and charges him for it." ~ No-Bobcat-6953

"NTA, but don’t give him any money when he inevitably blows through his retirement." ~ damiana8

"NTA. There's often a weird dynamic between parents and professional offspring as they still see you as a child.. For example my parents were having building work done and wouldn't listen to my advice (chartered engineer) over a local builder." ~ Still-Butterscotch33

"NTA. I’m a doctor with a speciality in nutrition. I still remember when they called me, “oh Dr Nobody told us [X fact I had told them several times over 2 years]!” I almost screamed when I got off the phone. But at that point, I realized they’ll never listen to me about health stuff (or frankly, treat me like an adult)."

"They made my sister, a blue collar worker (no shade!), their medical proxy and power of attorney. I just tell her my medical opinion and she says it like she thought of it because they listen to her."

"I also let myself off the guilt-hook for them moving forward. If they had listened to me about simple health changes 15 years ago, they wouldn’t be where they are today. They are literally 1 event away from nursing homes; and they will not be able to find one that takes both of them with the different types of disabilities that they have."

"I say this so you don’t feel guilty when your dad gets scammed again." ~ LilithOG

"NTA. As a Financial Advisor you no longer have any duty to monitor and advise. In fact, you may be conflicting with their current FA. Your client has made a decision."

"But as an adult living descendant, you are avoiding a lot of hard choices. Your father has record of making poor financial decisions. He thinks they are in a growth phase when they should be in a conservative sustainable state. How many Business Life Cycles do you think they can ride out?"

"You may have to take conservatorship at some point. Your parents are now marks, and everything will becoming for them. Every dollar they lose will be one less for you to solve their future problems."

"I say, pitch in if only to to monitor how it's doing. Be ready to intervene. Enough bad decisions and they are living on your couch. You are not the asshole but ready to be one." ~ Aromatic_Base_3749

"NTA, I’m not a financial advisor but this feels exactly like my dad. What you do isn’t good enough but somebody else can do the same job worse and cost him more and he’d say look how amazing they did."

"Over the years the amount of suggestions I’ve had for him that he completely ignored, solar panels, stocks, purchasing additional houses, home battery, bitcoin, electric car, energy bills."

"They have money but was never interested in investing properly, he didn’t want a financial advisor because 'they take a huge cut'. No matter how much I explained that you can literally just leave them to it, they want your investments to do well, he said why would they want me to do well. Because it’s their job. Yeah, no he couldn’t be convinced."

"So now he’s retired and trying to manage it all himself and clearly has no idea." ~ Jonny_rhodes

OP is justified refusing to help, but may regret that choice later.

More For You