Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Woman Perplexed When Son Tells Her She Can't Be Friends With His Wife's Mother

Two people clinking wine glasses
Klaus Vedfelt/Getty Images

One of the most stressful parts of starting a new romantic relationship is meeting your partner's family.

If there is anything more stressful, it's when our family meets their family.


Though it's something of a cliché, it's sadly not uncommon for in-laws to have less-than-cordial relationships.

As such, couples usually breathe a huge sigh of relief when they discover their families do, indeed, get along.

The son of Redditor Grandma_Muffin169 recently got married.

After meeting the mother of her son's new bride at their wedding, they instantly hit it off and became fast friends.

Much to the surprise of the original poster (OP), however, her son and daughter-in-law (DIL) were anything but elated by this news.

Confused by the whole situation, the OP took to the subReddit "Am I The A**Hole" (AITA), where she asked fellow Redditors:

"AITA my son and DIL want me to not be friends with the other MIL."

The OP explained why she was perplexed by her son's reaction to her friendship with her DIL's mother:

"My son and DIL got married around three years ago."

"I met my DIL mother ( I will call her Emma) at the wedding. Emma and I became fast friends which was a pleasant surprise."

"We went to the same high school and somehow just never met."

"I see her almost every week."

"I was invited to her birthday that was in late October."

"It was her family and a few friends."

"It was at a restaurant."

"The issue was that my son and DIL were surprised to see me there."

"I didn’t hide the fact that we were friends."

"Also, me going to Emma's birthday wasn't mentioned by me since I have had a crazy month."

"It just didn’t come up."

"I thought the celebration was fun, but I got a call from my son that he doesn't want me to be friends with Emma anymore."

"I messaged Emma, and she also got a similar request."

"We talked it over and decided we aren’t going to end our friendship."

"We both think this is silly."

"I told my son, no."

"Emma did the same."

"And they both blew up."

"My son is pissed, and claims we are ganging up on them and this is the reason we should not be friends."

"I’m just kinda confused because I don’t see his point at all, so I came here."

"AITA?"

Fellow Redditors weighed in on where they believed the OP fell in this particular situation by declaring:

  • NTA - Not The A**hole
  • YTA - You're The A**hole
  • NAH - No A**holes Here
  • ESH - Everyone Sucks Here
  • INFO - More Information Needed

The Reddit community agreed that the OP was not the a**hole for becoming friends with her DIL's mother.

Everyone agreed that most children would be thrilled to know their in-laws were getting along as well as the OP did with her DIL's mother, with nearly everyone speculating that this might be owing to some marital difficulties between her son and DIL:

"NTA."

"But I am wondering if there is more to the story that explains why son and dil are insisting on this."- Antique_Elk7826

"NTA."

"But I would love to know why they don’t want their mothers to be friends."

"Most people would be overjoyed!"- Wonderful_Horror7315

"Your son saying you're 'ganging up' on them is literally just two friends both saying no to the same dumb request lol."

"You don't need permission to have a friend, keep doing your weekly hangouts."

"NTA."- SillySubstance7215

"NTA."

"Your son and his wife sure are, though."

"No one else gets a vote in your friendships."

"Just don't talk about them, nor give advice unless asked, etc."- KatzAKat

"NTA."

"Time for your son and DIL to sit down with both of you and explain what - exactly - their problem is, because I think a LOT of married couples would love it if their parents became friends (or at least, friendly with each other)."

"But no, you guys absolutely aren't the a**holes for remaining friends."

"Unless there's a huge chunk of context you've left out that would explain it, this is a deeply unreasonable request."- helenaflowers

"NTA."

"As an adult have every right to be friends with anyone you want."- Duncanhinds

"NTA."

"Sounds like they don't want the two of you to 'compare notes' on each other's kids."

"Did your son do something shady he doesn't want DIL to know about?"

"I'd also ask Emma the same thing for DIL."- NeffAnnBlossom4eva

"There is definitely missing information here from them."

"They at least need to offer a reasonable explanation for the request, not that it should influence your decision."

"Just so you have some context for such a silly request."

"There’s something they’re not telling you."

"NTA."- Mean-Payment-9892

"Absolutely NTA."- MK_King69

"NTA."

"My money is on that fact that, as a couple, they are routinely lying about something to one or both sides of the family and they don't want the two moms comparing notes."- absolutnonsense

"NTA."

"Your son and daughter-in-law are being extremely controlling and unreasonable."

"As adults, you and Emma are completely free to choose your own friends, and your friendship has nothing to do with them."

"It is bizarre that they think everything in their parents' lives revolves around them or constitutes a conspiracy against them."

"You did nothing wrong by being friends with the other mother-in-law; in fact, it should be a positive thing that you get along well."

"Stand your ground."- Monmon71122

"NTA."

"But it's very weird they don't want you to be friends."

"Like they are hiding something, maybe telling you and her different stories."- GBOC80

"NTA."

"I'd bet they want the option to scapegoat one MIL to the other, but they can't do that if the MILs are in regular communication."-BellesNoir

"They want to hit both families up for support, if not money, and pit you all against each other."

"That and/or they are lying to one or both of you."

"NTA."- Dry-Clock-1470

"I think that most married folks would LOVE for their families to have good relationships."

"Your son's/DIL's reaction suggests that there's something going on here that they aren't sharing with you."

"NTA - they don't get to veto your friendships."

"I would definitely ask them (calmly) why they think you're 'ganging up on them'"

"That sounds REALLY defensive."- wesmorgan1

"Are your kids both fresh out of high school?"

"Because 'OMG, our moms are friends' is such a high school take on all this."

"I for one would be thrilled for my parents and in-laws to get along so well."

"NTA."

"You and Emma are adults, therefore you both get to determine whether you remain friends."

"Nobody else gets a say."

"Your married children are also adults, and they need to start acting like it."- MadameBlue42

There were some, however, who felt that more information was needed to make a judgment:

"INFO: What did your son say about WHY he doesn’t want yall to be friends, and WHY he has the impression that you gang up on them?"- MusicHoney

"INFO."

"As someone who may be uncomfortable with this situation, I think it’s one of two things."

"Son and DIL are having issues themselves and want separate 'sides' for people to take."

"Son and DIL don’t trust or aren’t close with you or the other MIL, and don’t want the friendship to influence their relationship."

"An example of this could be if they want a limited relationship with her, but not a limited relationship with you; it would be awkward if you’re friends with her, but also they could be worried about you giving too much info that they don’t want her to know."

"You have to ask your son for more information, but it sounds like he doesn’t trust you enough to tell you."- SuitableLeather

"INFO."

"Are you and/or Emma commenting on or critiquing your children's lives in any way?"

"I don't just mean the obvious stuff, but the more subtle things like asking questions that show your opinion on something."

"And do you and Emma talk about your kids regularly?"

"If you both regularly give suggestions and critiques to your kids, it is very valid that they don't want to deal with you and Emma talking to each other about things (like when you want them to have kids, where you prefer they live, how you want holidays celebrated) and then both of you separately bringing that up to your kids."

"That can easily be seen as ganging up by your kids."- nannerdooodle

"Info: how have you seen each other every week for 3 years without your kids knowing?"- havingaconniption

The OP later returned with an update, sharing what she planned on doing upon reading everyone's responses:

"I am going to message my son and ask point blank why us being friends is such an issue."

"Someone asked if they were having issues in their marriage, and I actually think they might be."

"My son didn’t tell me about any marriage issues, but in the summer I do know they had a big argument and he came alone to a few events."

"I thought that was done with, though."

It's hard to imagine why anyone would get so upset, or even upset at all, to learn that their mother had become friends with their mother-in-law.

As many suspected, a more than likely reason might be marital strain.

Something the OP and her new best friend better discuss with their children pretty soon.

More For You