Canadians have a reputation for being polite. Whether it's deserved or not, thats the perception on the global stage.
But is saying "please" and "thank you" or "I'm sorry" ever a bad thing?
A Canadian turned to the "Am I The A**Hole" (AITAH) subReddit for feedback after their politeness became a problem for their boyfriend.
Similar to AITA, the AITAH subReddit allows posters to ask for advice and post about ending romantic relationships—both things that are banned on AITA. However, there are no required voting acronyms—only suggested ones—and no official final judgment declared.
HugsNotPlugs asked:
"AITAH for saying please and thank you too much?"
The original poster (OP) explained:
"I (female, 38) have a boyfriend (male, 50) who is usually a very nice person to strangers and people in service industries. Sometimes he gets short with them and it makes me wildly uncomfortable."
"Anyway, I am what I would consider to be a polite person. I am Canadian from Medicine Hat, Alberta. This is how I was raised."
"For example:"
"Me: 'Can I please get a flat white?'."
"Person: 'Yes, sure, would you like sugar?'."
"Me: 'No, thank you'."
"Person: 'That’s $5.50'."
"Me: 'Thank you' and I pay and then say 'thank you' again when they hand it to me.
"My boyfriend claims this is excessive and wants me to stop."
"AITAH for refusing to stop saying please and thank you excessively when it bothers my boyfriend?"
"TLDR; I say, please and thank you a lot and it drives my boyfriend crazy. I might be the a**hole because I refuse to stop even though he asked me to."
Some Redditors weighed in by using the AITA voting acronyms:
- NTA - Not The A**hole
- YTA - You're The A**hole
- NAH - No A**holes Here
- ESH - Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - more information needed
Redditors decided the OP was
"NTA. It’s called basic human decency. I couldn’t be with someone who didn’t do the same." ~ LuciferLovesTechno
"We always said 'please' when we asked for anything from anyone, ESPECIALLY service workers, and 'thank you' any time anyone gave us anything. That includes drive-thrus, ticket sellers at the cinema, delivery drivers, hotel desk clerks, everyone, every time."
"But when I was in college (I attended an Ivy League school on full scholarship), the trust fund kids were actually offended by me thanking 'the help' and being polite to janitors and dining hall workers. They acted like it was a privilege for other people to serve them. Like they were doing the service workers a favor by 'giving' them a job and the workers should be thanking them."
"It's a f*cked up attitude, but I've seen it a lot from people who grew up with money. Especially ones that grew up with housekeepers or nannies." ~ MohawMais
"why is he trying to be controlling of your politeness? What else does he try to control? I didn't realize how controlling my ex was until I got away from him." ~ Honey_Broad
"Yeah, it's concerning that he wants her to be more rude. What does he gain from that?" ~ _slagathor_
"NTA—saying please and thank you is easy to do, costs nothing, and generally makes the recipient feel acknowledged and appreciated. I am like you; I say thank you for the smallest gesture."
"Try to say please whenever asking for something. I'll die on this hill. I spent half a lifetime in the service industry and have been on the receiving end of rude, brusque people that don't seem to know how to be polite." ~ MadGeller
"Please and Thank You should be part of everyone's everyday language. What country is he from where it's annoying to always hear please and thank you?" ~ SkyRemarkable5982
"It’s North A**holia." ~ Any_Bookkeeper_6227
"I say please and thank you to my Google Home device. Just force of habit." ~ meggatronia
"I say please and thank you to Alexa, so when the machines take over, maybe they'll kill me quickly." ~ FakinMyWay_Downtown
"Yup, I say please and thank you to Siri!" ~ CatPurrsonNo1
"Me too. I also say please and thank you to my cat and dog." ~ Bulky_Psychology2303
"I said thank you to the cop when he gave me a speeding ticket." ~ BLTplease2030
"He's in his 50s and is a man... That should be enough information right there; too many men that age have zero respect for anyone that is in the service industry unless they worked in it themselves." ~ Croatoan457
"I’m Canadian, but that just sounds like basic manners. Please and thank you is normal and expected I think." ~ katenotwinslet
"My dad (94) and I even say please and thank you with each other in the house for things like bringing a cup of coffee and stuff. There is nothing wrong with manners."
"I wish more people used their manners, especially out and when dealing with service workers. You may be the only person that appreciates their effort all day. Definitely NTA." ~ CorrectCondition9458
"I’m not even Canadian, and that sounds like basic manners." ~ sesamesnapsinhalf
"It drives him crazy because hes an a**hole and you're a walking reminder of how easy it is to be nice." ~ inspiring_potato
"WTF. NTA. Being polite is not a flaw. And it's showing respect for fellow human beings. ~ IrrelevantManatee
"This has nothing to do with cultural differences. Your boyfriend does not normally treat service people well if he thinks saying please and thank you is overdoing it."
"Wake up and smell the coffee sweetheart. Your boyfriend is a condescending a** who thinks he’s better than those who work in the service industry. Quit making excuses for him." ~ Intelcourier
"I'm English, we are brought up to use manners. I was in Canada years ago and went into a burger joint, sat down, and a waitress gave me a menu. I said thank you."
"Came back a few minutes later and I ordered, said please and thank you when she took my order. Another girl came and asked me if everything was OK, I said 'yes, thanks'. When I finished, I went to the counter to pay, the owner refused payment, and said his staff had mentioned how polite I was and told me not many people use manners."
"This was in Medicine Hat, Alberta. Just shows how manners are the right thing to do." ~ Apprehensive-Low-764
"NTA, and why on earth would you let your boyfriend convince you that being less polite would be better? I hate it when people treat retail workers and waitstaff like 'the help', like those people are below them and don't deserve politeness." ~ PinkedOff
"NTA.What you have described is a perfectly reasonable interaction.Decades ago I worked at a full service deli in a grocery store. One evening a woman strode up to the counter and said, “Give me 250g of Black Forest ham!” in a demanding tone. I looked at her and said, “You do realize you have to pay for it? Then she realized how rude she had sounded and said Please and thank you. His reaction is weird and uncalled for. ~ GalianoGirl
"How could you EVER be the a-hole for saying please and thank you in a non-sarcastic manner? Jfc, girl. Have some self-respect.He’s dating someone 12 years younger than he is because no woman near his age would let him get away with this shit.NTA, dump him. wtf. ~ starplain
"Tell grandpa to chill ~ OldStinkyWizardEyes
"NTA. How else does he make you feel uncomfortable?
Basic decency is not a flaw~ zedicar
"NTA. Being polite and kind hurts no one. ~ Wooden_Tell5780
"Furthermore, for me, if my person is extremely polite to strangers, it makes me more appreciative of them and fortunate I'm with them ~ DerFledermaus
"NTA-fellow Canadian here, this seems like a totally normal and polite interaction. Why does your partner have a problem with manners? ~ Impressive_Moment786
"NTA. That's just who we are. You could flip it and tell him that he's being super rude by not saying please & thank you. Because that's my gut reaction when I watch US TV. It's a cultural difference and he needs to get over it. ~ MusketeersPlus2
"I'm American and all of my interactions are similar to op. No way would i date someone who not only is rude to service workers but who also wanted ME to be rude. ~ W0nderingMe
"Let's not give him that partial pass. Being an AH is not strictly cultural. Lots of us in the US are polite and say please and thank you regularly. This guy is just a rude jerk. ~ PinkedOff
"I would probe this with him a little bit deeper. Questions like, 'Why exactly does this bother you?' Is it jealousy, like he thinks you're automatically hitting on every person you speak to because you're simply polite?"
"Or would he prefer to date a complete a**hole?"
"Every time someone does something for me, I thank them. The circumstances don't really matter much, it just happens.Oh, and NTA, of course." ~ anothersip
"He's upset because you're polite and wants you to stop being polite? I don't get it. Why would saying please and thank you bother anyone? It's a nice thing."
"NTA. Him being upset doesn't require you to stop doing something perfectly reasonable that no reasonable person could possibly object to. You go on being kind and polite, OP, that's awesome." ~ TelevisionMelodic340
OP is unfailingly polite to the people providing services to her.
Why this bothers a man 12 years her senior is anybody's guess.















