It's always frustrating when we're talking with a friend, and they seem to be trying to "one-up" us, or to show how they can relate to something they truly don't understand.
Sometimes, all anyone needs is a little sympathy or a shoulder to cry on, as it were, and our friends instead turn the situation to be only about them.
It can be equally frustrating, however, when we're accused of co-commiserating or one-upping our friends when that was not our intention at all.
Redditor Dragon_Birdie was enduring a chronic and very frustrating medical condition.
A condition that had a significant impact on the original poster (OP)'s future.
When the OP brought it up with a friend who had similar symptoms, she was met with anything but sympathy.
Having some doubts about how she handled things, the OP took to the subReddit "Am I The A**hole Here" (AITAH).
Unlike the similar 'Am I The A**Hole' (AITA) subReddit, AITAH allows Redditors to ask for advice on issues that are not permitted on AITA, such as asking for advice or posting about ending relationships. Voting acronyms aren't required, and no final judgment is declared.
The OP asked fellow Redditors:
"AITAH for saying I can't get pregnant?"
The OP explained why both a friend and her husband felt the need to call her out when she brought up a certain medical condition:
"I 36 F[emale] have a medical condition for which I have medication."
"With this medication, I am not allowed to become pregnant."
"I tried to go off medication (it has a 5-6 month period for being completely gone and being allowed to become pregnant) which did not go well."
"I went into a burnout (ofc that was not the only cause) and wasn't able to work for a year."
"After a year I was supposed to start working again, and I decided to start the medication again."
"It took 5-6 months to start working again, but it helped me gain my energy back and I was able to get back to working 36h a week."
"I was talking with my therapist about the topic, as I have very strong emotional reactions to pregnancy- and child-related topics."
"We went through all of it and came to the conclusion that it's because I really want it, but am also terrified of going without medication again."
"It would be 5-6 months for the medication to be out of my system."
"Then the time to become pregnant, which isn't instant, then 9 months of being pregnant and the 5-6 months for the medication to start working again."
"I don't feel, with the recent recovery of my burnout, that I am able to do so."
"So even though I would really want it, I don't feel like I am able to due to my circumstances."
"We (my husband, 35 M[ale], and I) are friends with a couple who are not able to become pregnant due to infertility."
"They ended up adopting a sweet girl who has been part of their family for 3 years now."
"We were talking the other day and I told her that, although I know it is completely different, it feels like I can't get pregnant (explaining why and trying to be considerate of her situation)."
"She disagreed as it's not the same as infertility and feels like I should not tell people I can't get pregnant."
"The other day my husband and I were doing a cooking workshop."
"There was a lovely couple we met, and they told us they had a 3-year-old and asked us if we had children."
"I said that I would have love to, but are unable."
"On which my husband responded with, well, not really... (because I am not infertile like our friends), and it felt like I had to explain the complete situation as to why I said so."
"I don't always feel like explaining all of my situation to strangers."
"So am AITA for saying I can't get pregnant?"
Fellow Redditors weighed in, with some using the voting acronyms:
- NTA – Not The A**hole
- YTA – You're The A**hole
- NAH – No A**holes Here
- ESH – Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - More Information Needed
The Reddit community agreed that the OP did nothing wrong by telling people she couldn't get pregnant.
Everyone felt that the OP didn't deserve to be berated by her friend or her husband about her condition, agreeing that even if she didn't suffer from infertility, she still deserved sympathy and respect:
"NTA."
"You can't get pregnant for medical reasons, what those reasons are are no one's business."
"Tell your husband that you expect better discretion and support in the future."- Cautious_Draw5738NTA.
"Why the hell are your loved ones trying to be reductionist and incredibly pedantic about this?"
"There is no single form of 'true infertility'."
"If you can't have kids, you can't have them; the process behind it doesn't matter."
"Your 'friend' needs therapy for trying to gatekeep fertility struggles, and your husband needs to learn to stand by his wife, not make your life harder."- ZerotheHero000
"NTA."
"Being physically able to get pregnant doesn’t mean it’s medically safe or realistic."
"Your friend doesn’t own the definition of 'can’t have kids'.”
"And your husband correcting you in front of strangers was a dick move."
"You shouldn’t need to explain your entire medical history just to answer a simple question."- TheQuietCipher01
"I'm too sick to get pregnant."
"I don't tell everybody what body parts exactly are too sick to handle pregnancy, unless they ask."
"Never had I ever someone berate me for it."- Khani318
"Why does your husband feel the need to explain your private medical history?"
"There are different categories of 'can't get pregnant'."
"Hidieously unwise to go off meds is absolutely one of those categories, but nobody outside your marriage and immediate family needs the gory details unless you are comfortable sharing them."- Minflick
"NTA.
"your husband’s correction bothered me more than your friend’s reaction, and you are answering the question in the simplest way possible."- honeyfirms
"I am a girl who was born without a uterus, amongst other things."
"it’s a congenital disorder called mrkh."
"I have, what is possibly the most 'true' form of infertility."
'I would NEVER, EVER tell someone that they’re not actually infertile!"
"Or not to talk about it?"
"that’s crazy!"
"If that’s their experience, that’s their experience."
"... I can’t even imagine that."- eli00na
"I'm in a similar situation."
"Rather than saying I cannot have children, I say 'I cannot safely get pregnant due to some health issues' which is still fairly short and to the point but makes it clearer."
"But also if someone asks if you have kids, you don't need to tell them anything."
"Just say 'no we don't'."
"Anything else is oversharing."- TheGreenPangolin
"NTA."
"But."
'You don't have to explain to people you've just met why you don't have children."
'If they ask ? = Simply say because we don't."
"If they insist ? = How is it any of your business?'
"Because, I get that for someone that is truly infertile, they would love to trade that for pain and a pregnancy, which will not make them show an ounce of empathy for your situation."
"While you absolutely deserve the empathy as well, but an infertile person won't get that."
"As for other people, again, you can say 'we don't have kids' and not go into detail."- Naelyssa
"I understand your therapist correcting the infertile remark as it could be insensitive to people who are, however 'can’t' is for any reason that you cannot.'
"Totally reasonable to say and not delve deeper with anyone you don’t want to."
"NTA."- captainlux87
"NTA."
"Just because you are PHYSICALLY able to doesn't make it safe."
"If it isn't safe, you're unable to imo."- meowcatpanda
'NTA."
"But your husband needs to be on the same page as you about NOT having to explain anything to anyone."
"The conversation would have ended right there if not for your husband's unnecessary comment."
"I am sorry for you wanting a child but unable to."- Nevilles_Remembrall_
"Mental health is also health, so yeah, you can't get pregnant due to medical reasons."
"For people who want children really, really, really bad, but can't, anything related to babies and pregnancy stuff is a sensitive topic, so for them it might come across differently."
"I'd say, NTA."
"The husband is close to it though, with his side note, but I want to see it as awkwardness and not AH-ness."- DingesF
"NTA."
"You CANT get pregnant because of medical complications(aka the complications of not being on medication you need)."
"That's completely valid."- AffectionateMarch394
It would be one thing if the OP were outright lying to gain sympathy.
Even if she could, theoretically, get pregnant one day, it doesn't mean that she isn't in a sensitive and downright frustrating position.
Something both her friend and husband might have taken a moment to consider before shooting her down in the manner they did.















