Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Redditor Refuses To Help Support Bedbound Sister With Chronic Illness Unless She Rehomes Her Massive Dog

A dog peeking out of a gate in a kennel.
Sergio Mendoza Hochmann/Getty Images

Very few people are lucky enough not to have been in a situation where they needed to put their own life on pause to help a family member.

However, sometimes family members can't be helped until they start making an effort to improve their own lives.


More often than not requiring them to give up or let go of something that brought them great happiness.

The sister of Redditor Significant-Ad-8328 recently suffered a fairly devastating medical setback.

Seeing the toll that caring for their sister was taking on their mother, the original poster (OP) was ready to be more present for their sister.

However, the OP also knew their sister wouldn't fully recover unless she made a significant sacrifice.

A sacrifice the OP knew would make her sister incredibly unhappy.

Wondering they were wrong for feeling this way, the OP took to the subReddit "Am I the A**hole" (AITA), where they asked fellow Redditors:

"AITA: Withdrawing support from my chronically ill sister on the condition that she rehomes her dog?"

The OP explained why they felt it was imperative that their sister rehome her dog:

"My sister (autistic, history of trauma/DV) suffers from severe chronic illnesses (POTS, MCAS, Pernicious Anaemia)."

"She spent almost a decade bedbound before finally finding a treatment plan—diet changes and B12 injections—that gave her a miracle recovery."

"She went from being trapped in the house to walking 20k steps a day."

"Thrilled with her progress, she got a Belgian Malinois two years ago for physical security and emotional support."

"Given her vulnerability and past trauma, the dog became her lifeline."

"Tragically, the NHS abruptly stopped her B12 injections."

"She suffered a severe adverse reaction trying to restart them and is now back to square one."

'She has gastroparesis, is on a liquid diet, and is completely bedbound again."

"The medical negligence she has faced is severe enough that I am currently seeking legal advice on her behalf."

"Here is where the conflict starts."

"Our mother (60, with her own health issues) is her full-time carer."

"They both struggle with hoarding, and I have spent immense time and labor trying to clear their house, which has fallen into profound disrepair and is actively hindering my sister's recovery."

"Because my sister is bedbound, she is physically incapable of caring for a Belgian Malinois—they are a high-drive, demanding working breed."

"The physical and logistical burden of this dog is falling entirely on my mother, who is already drowning in full-time care duties."

"I told my sister she needs to rehome the dog."

"It is an impossible environment for the animal and a massive responsibility for our mother, whose own health will collapse under the strain."

"Due to her autism and past trauma, my sister has formed an extreme emotional attachment to the dog and refuses to part with it, while my mother refuses to intervene."

"I cannot keep acting as the crisis manager for a household that isn't willing to listen to reason."

"I told them that until the dog is rehomed to alleviate the burden on my mother, I am withdrawing my support."

"AITA for walking away from this situation?"

Fellow Redditors weighed in on where they believed the OP fell in this particular situation by declaring:

  • NTA – Not The A**hole
  • YTA – You're The A**hole
  • NAH – No A**holes Here
  • ESH – Everyone Sucks Here
  • INFO - More Information Needed

The Reddit community agreed that the OP was not the a**Hole for demanding their sister rehome her dog.

Everyone felt that the OP wasn't being vindictive or cruel, but simply realistic in pointing out that the dog is simply more than their sister can handle right now, even if some felt the OP could look for a rehoming solution that might make their sister happy:

"NTA."

"You can’t keep being the emergency support system for two adults who refuse to make changes."

"I understand why the dog means so much to your sister, but a Malinois needs far more than love, and your mother clearly doesn’t have the capacity to carry that responsibility indefinitely."

"Stepping back doesn’t mean you don’t care."

"It means you’ve reached the limit of what you can realistically fix."- 404dollnotfound

'NTA because wtf would someone choose a Malinois?"

"A former co-worker has two Malinois, and he's basically doing police training with them, to have them spend their energy."

"I've held one once on the leash and holy heck they are exhausting."

"Those are not typical breeds for having a dog."

"It's unfair to the dog big time."- curiousyara

"NTA."

"No one should get a malinois unless they are a competent dog trainer who is also operating a farm and can give that dog a real job."- outback-gnome

"NTA."

"A Belgian Malinois is an intense working breed, not a lap dog, and demanding that your disabled 60-year-old mother care for it inside a hoard while your sister is bedbound is completely unsustainable."

"Protecting your own sanity isn't abandonment."- Quoxxvalline

"I was ready to say YTA, then I read Belgian Malinois, so100% NTA."

"I am very attached to my dog and would need him more if I was bedbound, but mine is a velcro dog who wants to be a couch potato most of the time and not a Belgian Malinois."

"I sympathize with you all in this situation."- Pikeford

"NTA, but OH MY GOD, a malinois as a support animal?!"

"Was she high when she decided to get a dog like that in her condition?"

"Sorry for that outburst, but, PEOPLE, think before you do stuff like this."

"My God, you’re so not he a**hole here, seems like you’re the only voice of reason."- MessagefromA

"NTA."

"I’m not at all calling your sister cruel, but keeping a breed like that in this situation is animal cruelty."

"They need a ton of activity and a job to do to stay healthy and happy."

"Agree with others that maybe the best approach would be to have the dog go somewhere specific so sister can visit?"-Charming_Square5

"NTA."

"A Malinois is a very high-energy breed, a demanding breed, and it's bordering on inhumane for the dog to be stuck in that situation, as much as your sister loves that dog."

"If you haven't already, maybe try explaining that it is in the dog's best interest to re-home it because the dog cannot get the care it needs as of right now, and you cannot help in this current situation as is because it's an intense ask of you."- waxwickerdoll

"NTA."

"I was on your side as soon as I saw the breed name, tbh."

"The average healthy person has no business owning a Malinois."

"A chronically ill person who experiences long periods of being bedridden definitely has no business owning a Malinois."

"I say this as a chronically ill individual who is frequently bedridden and would be genuinely devastated if I had to give up my dog."-Cleromanticon

"NTA."

"We have a mal-gsd mix that was from a line to be more family dogs, but mal is gonna mal."

"I have an injury that flares up from time to time, so when we got the dog, I've trained a few things to help make those times easier (put the ball next to me on the couch, instead on the floor, different rooms have dog beds - each has their own name, find it games in the house, etc...) BUT I have also set up a plan."

"The dog goes to doggie day care on the regular AND I pay our dog trainer to come walk him sometimes when I am not up to it."

"The dog is still getting his needs met and I'm not putting the burden on anyone else."

"I didn't choose this dog, my partner did and that's a whole different can of worms."

"Your sister made a choice that fit a very small slice of her life and cannot seem to understand it's hurting the dog to live like it does."

"If you don't want to be the bad guy, call your local animal welfare office and see about a visit."- EquivalentTwo1

There were some, however, who did sympathize with the OP's sister, even if they still felt the OP was doing the right thing:

"NAH."

"Art of the possible in a complex situation where you are trying your best."

"Perhaps contact the Kennel Club or the breed associations and try to rehome the dog to a particular place rather than doing a general 'give the dog to a shelter', as it might help reframe removing the dog to a better place for the dog rather than giving it up."-peonyhen

The OP later returned with an update, thanking everyone who took the time to respond, and sharing how they intended to proceed:

"I want to sincerely thank everyone who took the time to read and comment."

"I didn't expect this to reach over 300k views."

"I will be looking for more amicable solutions regarding the dog's care, and will ensure that my mother and sister are connected to the right support agencies regarding the current circumstances."

"The safety, care, and quality of life for the dog is paramount and call the RSPCA, should they fail to meet the dog's needs."

"It's a very complicated matter due to the emotional, psychological, and physical toll these events have had on my family and I."

"I will be maintaining my boundaries at this given time, though I will seek out support and consider other options."

"I will be turning off notifications for this post now."

"Thank you all again for the overwhelming support, even those who were exceptionally blunt (I know that you meant well)."

Telling someone they need to get rid of their dog seems an almost unforgivably cruel thing to even suggest.

That being said, the OP isn't doing this to be cruel, but because they know it's an unfortunate but necessary step in their sister improving her well-being.

Hopefully, the OP's sister will recover enough to understand why the OP made this sad but necessary decision.

More For You