Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Parent With Back Spasm Livid After Husband Leaves Them At Home With Baby To Go Fishing All Day

Man fishing
Witthaya Prasongsin/Getty Images

Parenting is hard, and even brand new parents need breaks from time to time.

But when one parent is struggling with chronic pain, the fun plans their partner had in mind might have to wait, for the sake of their partner and for the sake of their baby, pointed out the members of the "Am I Overreacting?" (AIO) subReddit.


Redditor Substantial-Skill724 had an eight-week-old baby and a toddler with their husband, and they knew about his plans to go fishing for the day while they were home with the kids.

But when they got a sudden, terrible back spasm and struggled to move, the Original Poster (OP) was shocked that their husband made no change to his plans and left them for hours in pain while caring for their children.

They asked the sub:

"Am I overreacting for telling my husband that he should feel guilty for going fishing while I was home alone with a back spasm and a baby?"

The OP's husband had plans to go fishing while they were home with their two children.

"My husband took off work today specifically to go fishing."

"We have an eight-week-old baby and a toddler in pre-K."

"I didn’t have a problem with him going fishing when he first told me this plan last night, as he was planning to help in the morning (split the duties of getting the toddler dressed, making breakfast, packing lunch, feeding and changing the baby, etc.)."

But when the OP's back went into spasm, they hoped their husband would help.

"As I was getting dressed, I got a bad back spasm."

"I called him from upstairs to tell him I needed a few minutes and couldn’t move (I wasn’t even able to lift my foot to walk for about two minutes before I made my way to the bed to sit down)."

"He offered to help me, but there was really nothing to do, because I was just getting dressed at the time, so I just said to keep doing what he was doing downstairs to keep the morning routine moving along."

"He made our toddler breakfast, as I had already dressed him."

"When the worst of the spasm passed, I could at least walk (albeit slowly and carefully). I had put on my TENS unit and was planning to take some Advil."

The OP was surprised when their pain did not impact their husband's plans at all.

"I told him something along the lines of, 'I don’t think you can go fishing today; I’m going to need your help, I’m in bad shape.'"

"To be honest, I kind of assumed he knew this already."

"He said something like, 'I took off work to go fishing, I’m going fishing, you’ll be fine, look how helpful I was this morning!'"

"I argued back that I can barely move and wasn’t sure if I could safely lift or carry the baby."

"He had already made up his mind, so I got really short and kind of just shut down. To be fair, I know this is not my best quality."

"As he was leaving, he told me, 'Thanks for trying to guilt trip me.'"

"I said, 'You should feel guilty.'"

"His other arguments were that he was supposed to be working, so I would’ve been home alone either way. As you can probably guess, he’s fishing now."

The OP felt conflicted about how the morning went.

"Am I overreacting for feeling like he just showed me what his priorities are? I’m feeling so hurt by this, but I’m also in pain, so I’m not sure if the pain is just making me more sensitive."

"I understand that it sucks to change plans at the last minute and waste PTO, but these things happen."

"I know I would’ve been home alone if he were working, but the fact remains, he wasn’t working. He chose to leave me in pain to fend for myself."

"Also, he’s gone fishing five other times since the baby was born, and he was going alone this time, so it’s not like he was messing up plans with others."

"I don’t think I’ve complained about him fishing at all, despite having a newborn baby. Fishing is his biggest hobby, and he rarely goes out with friends or does anything else just for himself, so I like to think I’m very laid-back about the fishing."

"Also, before he left, I lifted, changed, and fed the baby to see if I was physically able do it if I was left alone, and I could, though uncomfortably."

"AIO?"

Fellow Redditors weighed in:

  • NOR: Not Overreacting
  • YOR: You're Overreacting

Some pointed out that the husband's PTO was more important for moments like this.

"Funny story. My husband had PTO to burn and booked a week off to relax, do house projects, etc. at the end of September."

'Guess what? My gallbladder decided to explode and get me sent to the ER in an ambulance. I spent 36 hours in the hospital, and his week off, I spent on the couch, drugged and useless, recovering from surgery."

"He did not complain ONCE." - mela_99

"NOR. Last Friday, my husband took off work to have an enjoyable day off. I woke up with neck spasms that took me to an ER."

"He didn't enjoy spending his day caring for me. Neither of us planned this. He did it, though. He didn't drop me off and then go home to do the gaming he planned, telling me to call when I was done. He didn't abandon me entirely once we got home, and I was settled with pain meds, but still struggling to live independently."

"You take care of your spouse when they are sick or injured. It's part of the bargain. Your husband should feel guilty."

"You should consider if this is the person you want to grow old with." - LadyCass79

"I look at it like this: when my wife’s health issues start popping up. I'd rather be there by her side than be anywhere else, no matter how uncomfortable it would get."

"My wife is now on the other side of that, surprise colon cancer, d**n near perforated my bowels before surgery, just got out of the hospital yesterday, weak as s**t. All happened over a 14-day period, she has never once wavered, her help means so much to me, and still I’m just happy we can be by each other’s sides."

"I don’t know why people marry others who don’t see them as some integral part of their being; they don’t feel complete when absent, but I’m also not trying to judge people for processing and feeling things differently, as we humans are so complex it’s never cookie-cutter."

"With that said, I still feel so sad for people in OP's situation." - Rennisa

"NOR. If he had been working and you needed him, he could have left; he should INSIST UPON IT. 'My wife is having an emergency. We have a newborn at home. I have to go.'"

"And his comment about how 'helpful' he was p**sed me off. He isn’t HELPING. It’s his home too. The babies are HIS KIDS TOO. He is your partner, not your assistant."

"And as a chronic pain patient, I absolutely feel for you there as well. I’m so sorry. Looks like your husband needs to spend a whole Saturday with the kids while you go do whatever the hell you want to do." - G_Ram3

"NOR. He left you with a newborn and a toddler knowing you were in pain and that lifting could exacerbate it."

"And going out fishing five times in the eight weeks since your baby was born is wild. That's a whole lot of absence. Fishing is an activity that takes up a significant chunk of the day."

"Does he actually pitch in significantly when he's not out fishing? Or is he one of those men whose attitude is, 'Just be grateful I changed a diaper that one time'?" - Correct-Sprinkles-21

Others agreed and were furious about other aspects of their conversation.

"'Look how helpful I was this morning!' I would have thrown something at him."

"He is their father. It is his job. He isn't 'helping.' For f**k's sake." - JoneseyP98

"No, he just put your child in danger."

"I fell down the stairs with my son precisely for this reason. Carrying him alone with a bad back."

"I'm now disabled for life. I saved the baby, though."

"Please don't be gaslighted into believing needing genuine help is selfish or guilt-tripping." - Beneficial_Pay4623

"Wait a second. So he wasn’t even going fishing with anyone else; it was all just on him? Would he rather go fishing alone than spend part of the day with his wife and child? That’s terrible. He couldn’t just go fishing later on once you were feeling better?"

"Are you 100% sure he’s actually going fishing when he says he is?"

"NOR. As a husband and father to a toddler, there’s no way I’m leaving my wife on her own in this situation. She wouldn’t have to ask; I would already know the right thing to do: fishing can wait. The river will still be there, and the fish will bite just the same." - philbydee

"NOR, my ex-husband did this once, leaving me, our six-month-old and eight-year-old for a fishing weekend with a predicted ice storm for our area. Power was out for two days. I took the kids to a hotel and divorced him later that year. Best decision ever." - pogostix615

"NOR. 'I’m so glad I took the day off, so I’m already here to help' is the correct response from a minimally decent partner here."

"'The fish aren’t going anywhere, let me at least stick around for an hour or two to make sure you’re really okay with the baby,' is the borderline icky, but understandable response."

"What your husband did was just a straight-up selfish jerk response. He failed both his wife and his children this one. Any reference to basic parenting being 'helping' is always a giant red flag."

"Have you gotten five days of solo time, out of the house, away from the kids, to recharge and either rest or do something YOU enjoy since the baby was born? I doubt it."

"Go ahead and schedule five days for yourself and let him know he’s in charge of his children those days, and that fishing won’t be happening until you’ve made at least some progress toward a more equitable split of the childcare responsibilities."

"If he doesn’t like that, or pushes back at all, I’d be seriously reevaluating one more year with this guy, let alone the rest of your life. Your kids will be old enough to notice this dynamic soon, too. They won’t think highly of him, and he’ll constantly whine about how they always want mom." - Express-Arachnid-782

The subReddit completely understood why the OP was upset and sided with them entirely, pointing out that leaving them alone would only make their pain symptoms worse, and it also put the baby in danger.

The fish could have waited, whereas the baby and their parents likely couldn't.

The OP would likely have to spend some time thinking about where they fit into their husband's priorities.

More For You