Few things bring greater joy than bringing a new baby home.
For all the joy it brings, however, it also comes with more than its fair share of anxiety.
Babies are delicate, vulnerable beings who require constant care and protection.
For some parents, even the tiniest thing could easily set them off.
Redditor medusnea and her husband recently welcomed their first child.
Naturally, as soon as the child came home, sleep became a precious commodity for both of them, so they decided to alternate nighttime shifts.
However, when the original poster (OP) learned that her husband wasn't giving their baby his full attention, she had trouble keeping quiet.
Seeing how upset she made her husband, the OP took to the subReddit "Am I The A**hoe Here" (AITAH).
Unlike the similar 'Am I The A**Hole' (AITA) subReddit, AITAH allows Redditors to ask for advice on issues that are not permitted on AITA, such as asking for advice or posting about ending relationships. Voting acronyms aren't required, and no final judgment is declared.
The OP asked fellow Redditors:
"First time parents, baby is 2 weeks old."
"I am a very anxious mom and am trying to follow guidelines about safe sleep to avoid risking SIDS."
"Husband and I are taking shifts at night so we can each get a few hours of uninterrupted sleep while the other attends to baby."
"I am pumping milk for baby every 3-4 hours, and it’s hard to get enough sleep between that and caring for baby."
"Today I learned that, during his turn / while I was sleeping in the other room, he put the baby on a couch cushion and 'nestled her in' before going outside to smoke for 10 minutes."
"I told him I don’t love that (makes me EXTREMELY anxious about SIDS), can he please put baby in the bassinet next time?"
"And then we proceeded to have a huge fight over it."
"He accuses me of not trusting him, and I am begging him to please just put baby in the bassinet for safety if he’s going to leave her in the space unattended."
"He said he doesn’t want to live being 'governed by fear' and I said, 'what do we gain by taking this unnecessary risk?'”
"He is great with the baby for everything else; it is just this disconnect on safe sleep guidelines that is the issue."
"And it feels like it’s become larger / representing something deeper, but I can’t pinpoint what that may be."
"He is extremely upset with me, and I’m at a loss of what to do."
"Am I the a**hole?"
Fellow Redditors weighed in, with some using the voting acronyms:
- NTA – Not The A**hole
- YTA – You're The A**hole
- NAH – No A**holes Here
- ESH – Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - More Information Needed
The Reddit community agreed that the OP was right to call out her husband.
Everyone agreed that the OP was only thinking of her baby's safety, and her husband needed to hear it:
"Baby goes in the bassinet or on the rug or in the playpen."
"Babies can roll, and it's dangerous to leave them on a chair/couch/bed because of a fall risk."
"NTA."
"Sometimes, calling a pediatrician's office and getting a neutral expert's opinion carries more weight."
"I assume you are both losing sleep and cranky, so appealing to authority can sometimes be the slap upside the head that makes your concerns valid."- 2dogslife
"Let me just say that babies learn to roll over... and they surprise you when they do."
"There is no warning, and your baby could roll right off the couch."
"Your husband needs to think about the baby's safety."- HeavenLeigh412
"NTA."
"Put the baby in a proper bed/basset, have a baby camera monitor watching over the baby while he's outside."
"Also make sure he's changing his jumper and washing his hands after having a cigarette before he's near the baby."
"Baby's skin rapidly absorbs the third-hand smoke and toxins from hands, mouth, and clothing contaminated with cigarette smoke."
"Babies exposed to these are 50% more likely to get respiratory infections like bronchitis and pneumonia, have an increased chance of asthma and ear infections, and have a significantly higher chance of SIDS; the toxins interfere with parts of the baby's brain that regulate breathing."
"If he must smoke, then best to designate a 'smoking jumper' or something he can take off before coming back into the house and wash his hands."
"I know your already paranoid, and I've probably made it worse, but the risks aren't worth it."- SuggestiveDucky
"NTA."
"His smoking is a risk factor for SIDS."
"If he’s leaving baby in unsafe sleep areas, that’s not a SIDS risk, but a suffocation risk."- Beneficial-Guess2140
"Habits practiced now will likely continue into the future."
"He needs to begin responsible parenting NOW."
"NTA."
"Habits practiced now will likely continue into the future."
"He needs to begin responsible parenting NOW. "
"ETA"
"NTA."- calacmack
"NTA."
"Never leave your child unattended."
"I know she’s only 2 weeks old now, but she’ll be rolling over before you know it."
"And they ALWAYS learn to roll over when you’re not looking."- Key-Garlic-1177
"NTA."
"Sadly my cousin was changing their baby's nappy on a changing mat on a table."
"Turned away to get a new diaper and the baby rolled and fell to the floor."
"At the inquest/court case, it was pointed out that the baby had never rolled before and was considered very young to even be able to roll."
"Additionally, the changing mat was concave to aid keeping the baby in place."
"It was found no fault on the parents, no case to answer."
"But they still had to live with the fact their baby died."
"Your husband needs to quit smoking and do a parenting course!"- MaryMaryQuite-
"I'd be more concerned about the cigarette contaminants he immediately brings in on his hands, clothes, and hair."
"Which he then transfers to a newborn."- Comfortable-Battle18
"My baby sister rolled off a low bed onto a soft carpet and broke her collarbone."
"You are NTA and not overreacting to leaving an unattended baby on a couch."- kuluvalley
"NTA."
"But you've got a serious husband problem if he can't follow the simplest safety recommendations without acting like a big baby himself."- Hefty_Peanut
"It is not about you not trusting him it is about him putting her in a safe place to sleep."
"What a dumba**."- SeaCommunication667
"You have a few issues here:"
"The baby falling off of the couch."
"The baby rolling INTO the couch cushions and suffocating."
"Babies who live in a home where people smoke have a higher risk of SIDS."
"The fact that your husband is completely ignoring your wishes."- guesswhoshereagain
"NTA."
"You’re not being anxious, he is being neglectful."- notreallysurewhat
"NTA."
"He is not 'great with the baby' if he's willing to compromise her safety by ignoring proven science related to safe sleep and SIDS."
"If he wants to argue with someone about it, haul his a** to the pediatrician for her next appointment and he can tell the pediatrician what he thinks is 'safe' for the baby."
"Let them tell him what an idiot he is."
"Honestly, the fact that he's throwing such a fit about this tells me he's probably not a very great partner in other areas either."
"Good partners don't act like this."- NorthernLitUp
"He said he doesn’t want to live being 'governed by fear'."
"'I'm not demanding that you feel terrified while you put the baby in the bassinette, Darling Husband, I'm just saying put the baby in the bassinette. Thank you!'"
"NTA."
"Why risk it?"- Senator_Bink
"Totally NTA, leaving a baby unattended for ten minutes is unbelievably dangerous."
"That’s not 'fear-based parenting'; that’s not even 'new school'.”
"His parents would have known better than to leave him unattended as a newborn."
“'Nestled in' on a couch cushion is even upsetting."
"If he means somewhere she couldn’t have rolled away from, like nestled between cushions, that in itself is a suffocation hazard."
"He should kind of take a hard look at himself."
"Time to grow up."- thedogwiththepaws
"Obviously."
"But my main concern is the jack@ss bringing the smoke on his clothes and residue on his hands as they go back to 'caring' for the baby that young."- GODLiKEDEVIL-
The OP later returned with an update, thanking everyone who took the time to comment and sharing where things currently stood between her and her husband:
"Thanks all for validating that I’m not being crazy with this."
"Husband is still pissed and went for a drive."
"Fingers crossed he comes around!"
It can't feel good to know your spouse doesn't trust you.
What the OP's husband needs to realize, however, is that the only feeling that could possibly be worse is knowing that you can't trust your spouse.
It's fair enough that the OP's husband doesn't want to be governed by fear, but the OP shouldn't need to live constantly in fear that her child could be hurt under her husband's care.
Something he'll hopefully realize when he returns from his drive.















