Giving birth is not a walk in the park.
There is a lot of pain and emotion involved.
And every mother in the birth process needs the most supportive environment possible.
So the guest list for delivery can be limited.
Redditor u/Expensive_Chapter_87 found herself in a dilemma regarding the birth of her first child, so she turned to the "Am I The A**Hole" (AITAH) subreddit for feedback.
Like AITA, the AITAH subreddit lets posters ask for advice and post about ending relationships—both things banned on AITA. However, there are no required voting acronyms—only suggested ones—and no official final judgment is declared.
She asked:
"WIBTAH for not wanting my child’s father in the delivery room?"
The original poster (OP) explained:
"I (26 F[emale]) am currently 34 weeks pregnant with my first child."
"My ex (30 M[ale]) and I broke up a few days ago after more than 3 years together."
"I caught onto our town’s swingers groups, open encounters subreddits, messaging multiple people trying to meet up for hookups since July."
"This is the second time this has happened."
"The first time I caught him, I was 12 weeks pregnant in June, also had been going on for months and he had been on dating apps too."
"I tried to make it work for the kid then: this time he straight up told me he wanted to be single and date other people in a few months."
"So I didn’t fight him on it, and we broke up."
"That was on Tuesday."
"He has been a little difficult to work with since."
"He expected us to stay friends, have keys to each other's places so he could come over during the night, still have my location, and he said he still wanted to text me about work, daily life, etc."
"He also mentioned separating and getting back together in a few years a couple times."
"I made it pretty clear that if we decided to end the relationship, that door was locked and shut."
"I’ll be friendly and amicable for co-parenting, but I will not be his friend."
"I’ve stuck to my word so far and will only reply to him if it’s about our child or the apartment we shared since I’m still on the lease until January."
"He will ask me something about our child, then change the topic immediately when I reply to ask why I took him off social media, turned off my location, etc."
"I have told him I am only trying to move on with my life, and I expect him to respect that just like I respect his choice to leave."
"He said there is no way for us to move on because we’re tied together for at least 18 years."
"Now I was told I might have to be induced at 37-38 weeks due to concerns for potential growth restriction."
"Baby has been measuring 11th or 12th percentile and right on the edge of the under 10% that worries my OB."
"When he and I were together, we did plan for him to be in the delivery room."
"Now that we’re broken up and seeing what happened, I’m not comfortable with him being there while I’m going through tremendous pain and so vulnerable."
"I already know he’s probably going to throw a fit, as this is also his first child."
"I’m not sure if I’m wrong for feeling this way, but just knowing he’s already looking at dating other people and everything that happened, I feel like having him there would stress me out emotionally so much."
"I’d be open to having him come immediately after birth, and he can do skin-to-skin but not for the actual pushing."
The OP was left to wonder:
"So WIBTAH?"
Some Redditors weighed in by using the AITA voting acronyms:
- NTA - Not The A**hole
- YTA - You're The A**hole
- NAH - No A**holes Here
- ESH - Everyone Sucks Here
- INFO - More Information Needed
Redditors decided the OP was NOT the A**hole here.
"Childbirth is not a spectator sport."
"If you have someone with you, it should be someone who you feel supports you." ~ Vivid_Sky_5082
"NTA. This guy wants to be single but to control your life too!"
"Lock that door tight and prioritize yourself and the baby; let the man-child play his games alone."
"Good luck with a safe delivery; wishing you well." ~ Haunting-Regrets
"Stress can slow down labor."
"The laboring patient should only have people who she feels comfortable with and who are able to support her in the way she wants and needs." ~ Havanese
"The nursing staff should support your decisions. You!"
"Can and must choose who will be in the delivery room to support you."
"This EX will not be there to support you!"
"He just wants a show."
"He is not who you want at your bedside while you are in labor!"
"A close woman friend and/or your mother will support you."
"If he is the sperm donor, he can pay child support!" ~ thehudagai
"Oh no!"
"If it's not the consequences of his actions."
"He wouldn't be in this mess if he kept it in his pants."
"You don't owe him ANYTHING."
"You may want to consult with a family attorney to protect yourself and provide for your child, including working out custody."
"Document EVERYTHING!"
"Communication via text would be beneficial, as it's all documented."
"Good luck, and may you have a smooth delivery." ~ Several_Leather_9500
"NTA. Childbirth isn’t a spectator sport."
"It’s one of the most vulnerable times in a woman’s life."
"I wouldn’t want to be vulnerable like that with someone who betrayed me." ~ relentless_fu*kery
"NTA at all, but far from your ex is."
"Do you have someone else you can call on for support?"
"This is a vulnerable, intense time, and the whole point of him being there was for support for you."
"This will be the opposite."
"Good luck, mumma-to-be."
"I hope it all goes really well, and I'm sorry you're dealing with a P[iece]-O[f]-S[hit]."
"Proud of you for having the courage to hold strong."
"Make sure you tell your OB, midwives, hospital, etc. that you are not okay with him in the room during delivery, and they will help with keeping him out."
"God, what a POS." ~ Puzzled-Farmer4692
"NTA. Your birth experience is solely about you."
"Your body, whether you want it to or not, is going to react negatively to any stress in the delivery room."
"Being stressed during labor can prolong it and lead to dangerous situations."
"Your body is designed to try and get you to a safe place to birth, regardless of how much we have evolved."
"This is about you and only you."
"A man who cheats on his wife does not get a say. He can come in after the birth." ~ EmptyPomegranete
"Are you actually married?"
"If so, the divorce should be started ASAP."
"Either way, keep him out of your life and your business."
"If he's going to pay child support and have visitation, go through the courts and make it exact."
"He cannot show up randomly, track your whereabouts, or question you about anything."
"Only communicate regarding the child."
"And no... he does not have to be in there during the birth."
"Tell your doctor ahead of time."
"And remind the staff the day of the birth."
"Anything that stresses the mother is going to be banned from the delivery room."
"Do not notify the father until after the baby is born."
"Even then, he should have limited and supervised access."
"Your description of him indicates that he just wants an open relationship with you... to do whatever he wants with no consequences."
"And he seems to believe, because of the baby, you will agree to this."
"You will need to convince the court that he is not a good role model for the child and cannot be trusted very well."
"You would be wise to get a lawyer to help with this."
"Since he referred to being 'tied together for at least 18 years,' it sounds like the baby is more of a way to lock you in so you cannot leave him."
"If you can afford it, consider not putting him on the birth certificate and being a single mom."
"If he wants anything to actually do with his child, he can petition the courts for a test."
"You are NTA." ~ R3pp3pts0hg
"NTA-The birth is about mom and baby and getting you both through it alive and healthy."
"Who is in the delivery room is completely up to you and should be someone who you feel comfortable with and who will support you."
"He is not that person anymore."
"I agree with other commenters- don’t tell him about the birth until after."
"Put your last name on the birth certificate."
"Make sure you get child support ASAP." ~ CallansFin
"NTA. He gets access to his child once it's born."
"He does not get access to your body or your medical event."
"I would not tell him anything until you are ready to see him."
"It may be the day of birth, or it may be days later depending on how you're healing."
"When you do tell him, you need to let him know that any rudeness or animosity from him will mean he'll be asked to leave immediately."
"And then only let him come over when you have people there to help advocate for you."
"Having a baby is a very vulnerable time - you don't need to put up with this." ~ friendlily
"NTA... get him for child support and tell him you'll be friendly for co-parenting and nothing more."
"When your lease is up, you're out, and there is no hanging out as friends or texting unless it's for the child."
"This manchild gives the rest of us men a bad name." ~ bobp929
Reddit is with you, OP.
He made his choices.
You have every right to decide who can and cannot be in the delivery room.
You need all the peace you can get.
Good Luck.















